Baking Bliss or Miss? The Mix Box Baking Subscription

Have you ever wondered about baking subscriptions? I was curious and decided to try one for myself. I chose The Mix Box baking subscription because, during my research, I found that they had pretty good reviews. So grab a snack and read on about my experience and my thoughts on the Mix Box subscription.

Affiliate Disclosure: Some of the links below are affiliate links, meaning at NO additional cost to you, I may earn a small commission if you click through and make a purchase. See full disclosure here.

What Is A Baking Subscription?

A baking subscription is a service that delivers baking-related products and materials on a regular basis, usually monthly. Depending on the subscription you choose, they will include a variety of items such as:

  • Pre-measured ingredients needed for the recipe. They don’t include perishable ingredients, such as eggs, milk, or butter.
  • A different recipe each month.
  • Some may include special tools or utensils needed for that specific recipe
  • Some subscriptions offer themed boxes, such as holiday-themed or seasonal ingredients.
  • They may also include instructional guides, tips, and videos to help you improve on baking skills and techniques.

They are popular with new bakers as well as experienced ones because they offer a convenient way to try new recipes and techniques without the hassle of shopping or hunting for a recipe. They are also great gifts for those who love to bake.

The Mix Box Baking Subscription

Mix Box by Homemade Bakers offers a monthly baking subscription service designed for both newbie and experienced bakers. Each box promises a new, delightful baking experience delivered right to your doorstep.

Subscription Options

Mix Box offers several subscription options, each geared to fit different needs and budgets. Here’s a breakdown:

  • Monthly Subscription: Ideal for those who want to try out the service without a long-term commitment. It’s priced competitively, offering a single baking project per month.
  • Multi-Month Subscriptions: These are available in 3, 6, and 12-month increments, and they offer a slight discount compared to the monthly plan. This option is perfect for committed bakers looking for a more economical deal.
  • Gift Subscriptions: These are available for those who want to gift a Mix Box subscription to a friend or loved one. They follow similar pricing structures but are packaged as a thoughtful, unique gift.

The Cost

Month-to-Month Plan: Priced at $34.95 per box with free shipping. This plan allows for monthly payments with the freedom to skip a month or cancel at any time.

3-Month Prepay Plan: Costs $33.95 per box, free shipping included.

6-Month Prepay Plan: Priced at $32.95 per box, free shipping included.

The boxes are shipped around the 7th of each month.

Pros and Cons Of Baking Subscriptions

When considering a subscription service like Mix Box, it’s important to weigh the advantages and drawbacks to determine if it fits your baking needs and preferences. This service offers a convenient and educational approach to home baking, but like any subscription, it may have certain limitations. Let’s explore some of the key pros and cons to provide a clearer picture of what this subscription entails and whether it might be a suitable choice for your baking adventures.


  1. Convenience: The subscription provides pre-measured ingredients and step-by-step instructions, making baking at home easy and accessible.
  2. Variety: With a new recipe each month, subscribers can try a wide range of desserts, enhancing their baking skills.
  3. Educational Value: Great for beginners and experienced bakers alike, these kits can teach new techniques and recipes in a fun, hands-on way.


  1. Limited Ingredient Supply: Essential ingredients like eggs, butter, and milk are not included, requiring additional shopping.
  2. Cost: Compared to buying ingredients in bulk, the subscription can be more expensive, especially if one is already equipped with baking skills and recipes.
  3. Waste Potential: For those who don’t bake frequently, the monthly delivery might lead to unused ingredients and potential waste, especially if one forgets to skip a month or cancel in time.

What Was In My Mix Box?

My contents were for a carrot cake. The ingredients were pre-measured and in numbered bags. There was a card for the ingredients that I needed that were not in the box, such as carrots, eggs, cream cheese, butter, and milk, and the equipment you would need. A small numbered bag with all the spices needed plus 2 small bottles of measured vanilla. One for the cake and the other for the frosting. It also included a small bag with 2 toothpicks for checking the doneness of the cake.

A booklet with the instructions. In order to remake this recipe, you will need to keep the card that has all the ingredients and the measurements for each, and the booklet.

It would have been much easier, in my opinion, to have just one card with all the ingredients and instructions.

My Experience With Mix Box

The box was well packaged. I took out all the bags and began to follow the instructions, which, by the way, were very clear and easy to follow. But as I started adding the ingredients per the instructions, I noticed that I had 2 bags marked with the number 3.

This would have confused a new baker. The larger bag with the number 3 should have been number 4. It was the measured powdered sugar for the frosting. The smaller bag that was numbered 3 was the spices.

By following the instructions and the numbered bags, an inexperienced baker would have added the powdered sugar to the cake batter. Therefore they would not have the powdered sugar for their frosting.

I know mistakes are made, we are human, after all, but this is a business, and I believe they should have double-checked the contents before sending the box.

The equipment list called for 2 8-inch cake pans. I only had 9-inch cake pans, but the cake turned out fine. Thank goodness. I was not going to run out and buy 2 8-inch pans.

The Verdict

The cake was delicious. My family absolutely loved it. I got many compliments. The convenience of the ingredients being pre-measured was great. It did save me some cleanup time.

The instructions were very easy to follow. The only blimp was the incorrect labeling of the bag containing the powdered sugar.

I would recommend Mix Box, although it was a little pricey, many would find it worth the price due to the convenience.

I didn’t have to make a list and go shopping for the ingredients. They were delivered right to my door.

Check out Cratejoy They have many different baking subscriptions with a variety of pricing. You might just find one that will fit into your budget.

Final Thoughts

Wrapping up my thoughts on the Mix Box baking subscription, I’d say it’s a pretty neat choice for anyone who wants to bake without all the fuss of measuring and buying a bunch of different ingredients. The carrot cake kit I tried was mostly a breeze to use, even though there was a small mix-up with the labels. Having everything pre-measured and sent to your door is super handy, especially if you’re busy or new to baking.

But, let’s talk money. It’s not the cheapest option out there, and you’ll still need to grab some basics like eggs and milk. So, it’s really about whether you think the convenience is worth the extra cost. In the end, Mix Box is a solid pick for making baking easier and fun, but how much you’ll like it might depend on how much you bake and what your budget looks like.

Have you ever tried a baking subscription? If so, what was your experience? Please leave me a comment below

And As Always

Keep On Baking!


Share the Love

1 thought on “Baking Bliss or Miss? The Mix Box Baking Subscription”

  1. I love to bake. I doubt I’d join a subscrition plan — I’d find it hard to keep up with it. Thank you for your acticle it hit all the key points I was wondering about. — Sharon


Leave a Comment